For anyone that loves a TV display full that subtext and hidden connections, American fear Story is a goldmine. Because its inception, the anthology horror series has noted season after season the interlocking stories, imagery wealthy in allusion, and also references to actual events and people that carry out clues come the meaning behind the narrative. There"s no shortage of subject to traction at in any given season.

You are watching: American horror story circles of hell

Because the this, there are plenty of fan theories about the show. Some point to the means in which every of the seemingly different seasons regularly overlap, when others attract parallels come the similarities in between the fictional civilization of American fear Story and also actual American fear stories. Yet there"s one concept in certain that seeks to connect American horror Story to one of the most formative pieces of Western literature in history.

The divine Comedy, an epic poem created in the beforehand 14th century by the Italian writer Dante Alighieri, provides a fictionalized account that the author"s journey into Hell, climate Purgatory, and then come Heaven. The first part, recognized as Inferno, depicts Dante"s journey into nine distinct circles of Hell, each of which space synonymous with a particular type of sinful behavior. In order, they are Limbo, Lust, Gluttony, Greed, Wrath, Heresy, Violence, Fraud, and also Treachery.

Some American horror Story pan think that there may be a correlation between these nine circles and also the nine periods of the show.

The concept that every season that American fear Story thus much represents one of the ripe circles that hell illustrated in Dante"s Inferno has been roughly for a lot much longer than there have been nine periods of the show. A quick search will reveal that fans have actually been discussing this theory on the series" Reddit board for years. The supporters of the theory got a significant shot in the eight in 2017 once Ryan Murphy, who produced the series along through Brad Falchuk, addressed it.

In a since-deleted Instagram article (via Inverse), Murphy put up what appeared to be his own take top top the theory. Fans have long disputed which season correlates with which one of Hell, and Murphy apparently did assigning the his own. As much as Murphy experienced it in 2017, those correlations were: Murder House (season 1) represents Limbo, Hotel (season 5) represents Gluttony, Freak Show (season 4) to represent Greed, Roanoke (season 6) to represent Anger, Cult (season 7) represents Heresy, Asylum (season 2) represents Fraud, and also Coven (season 3) represents Treachery. The short article was made before the presence of Apocalypse (season 8) or 1984 (season 9), yet it"s not hard to check out them lining up with the other two circles, Violence and also Lust, respectively.

However, just because the theory seems to have acquired a rubber stamp of approval indigenous Murphy self doesn"t median everyone is buying it. As with all ambitious fan theories tying a decade"s worth of TV periods to details elements the a famed work of literature, the Divine Comedy/American fear Story hypothesis has an ext than a few holes in it.

First is the truth that if Murphy self reportedly discovered connections between the circles of Hell and the miscellaneous seasons, there"s quiet a lot that doesn"t enhance up. Girlfriend may have clocked that in Murphy"s list of connections, everything is the end of order. One would certainly think the if there was an on purpose to make correlations in between the two, season 1 the the present would complement with the very first circle that Hell, and also so on.

Fans have readily available their very own interpretation the the correlations that do line up. For instance, Reddit user u/Supreme000 made the case that if girlfriend reverse-match the seasons and circles the Hell, you discover correlations. Murder House would certainly then stand for Treachery, Asylum would represent Fraud, Coven would represent Violence, and also so on. 

There room compelling disagreements to be made for each, however at the end of the day, it"s no actually hard to find aspects from any type of given season the American fear Story the might enhance up with the principle of Treachery or Violence. As Reddit user u/Yesveronica detailed in a different thread ~ above the subject, "Ryan Murphy humored the principle in one Instagram write-up but...each season incorporates a plethora of different sins and nobody have the right to seem come agree top top a key sin for each season...It would have been a cool ide had lock planned it from the obtain go, yet they didn"t."

Even still, there are other ways that you have the right to see links in between Dante"s work and also American fear Story. Inferno and the other sections the The divine Comedy are an allegorical text about specific aspects of Christianity, yet they additionally contain lots of commentary about society and politics modern-day to Dante"s day. There space many personalities through all 3 sections who are either attracted from history, such together the old Roman poet Virgil, or who represent someone who lived in Dante"s time. In casting these real-life numbers in his fantastical story, Dante was giving readers with his own thoughts and also opinions on castle (via Ancient background Encyclopedia).

One could make the instance that American fear Story does a similar thing. The show typically features characters, plot lines, and imagery that room either straight related to things in the real world or room meant come evoke them. Take, because that instance, the Cult season, which features personalities that offer as commentary on modern political concerns like American news media, society justice movements, and the rise of Trumpism. Additionally consider just how Stevie Nicks appears as herself together a witch in Coven. The present may no be using the structure of Dante"s writing, yet one might argue the there"s still a heat of inspiration in between the two works.

See more: Soul Calibur 6 Female Character Creation Female, 18 Soul Calibur Creations Ideas

And who knows? perhaps the upcoming tenth season of American horror Story will view its personalities heading to Purgatory.